The live-action How to To Train Your Dragon is almost a shot for shot a copy of the original, where every sequence, character, and set piece just isn't quite as great, with one exception.
That exception is Gerard Butler who reprises his role as the protagonist's father and viking leader, again emphasizing the copycat nature of HTTYD which has hit theaters just 15 years after the original animated masterpiece from DreamWorks.
Director Dean DeBlois returns for the remake, adaptation, or whatever this clone should be called and delivers and adequate job of translating the work of animators to live-action, the background players and sets feel inauthentic and less dynamic, reading like a stage play where it's tough to buy what's happening on screen.
The lead cast, for the most part, are great even if it feels like they're imitating what we've seen before, but what holds the new How To Train Your Dragon back is that it feels simply "less than" what came before. The pacing is a bit off, the support characters aren't fleshed out enough, the music feels familiar but not powerful enough, and some of the emotional beats are lacking.
The biggest sin though is that when the original released in theaters, just months after Avatar took the world by storm, its own dragon flight sequences seemed superior and more epic. In the live-action HTTYD, this is a big miss and the earlier flight sequences with Toothless are bad, shot with shaky cam and unclear sense of scale and speed.
Overall, 2025's How to Train Your Dragon is good, but not good enough to justify its existence to viewers of the originals. It's disappointing and I can only hope the sequels attempt to innovate and improve instead of trying desperately to just be another copy of the work of the original crew.